Why Are Discrimination Studies Among Protections So Important?

July 6, 2020

Discrimination studies are an essential factor in the design of any electrical installations. Professionals carry out an exhaustive analysis of the electrical protections needed to guarantee the continuity of supply in case of failure. A good discrimination study allows the coordination of different protections at different levels of electrical installations.

In fact, the proper setting of the protective devices allows us to easily identify where the fault has occurred. More specifically, the selective coordination generally describes the selection of the protective devices to isolate the overcurrent condition so that the device nearest to a fault will trip rather than any device further ahead of it.

What is a selectivity study?

The terms “discrimination” and “selectivity” refer to the electrical current tripping of a device or piece of equipment and describe the same concept. This is due to the system being coordinated to discriminate between incoming and outgoing devices and prevent any further outgoing fault current from affecting the entire system.

Electrical engineers often produce a discrimination (selectivity) study at various stages within a project. The main point of the discrimination study is to demonstrate that:

  • Electrical equipment is protected by the system protection equipment (circuit breakers etc).
  • The protective devices have compatible characteristics to ensure that protective equipment closest to a fault, operates first.
  • Electrical equipment not involved with the fault remains in service to guarantee the power supply

An electrical network could be exposed to different types of overcurrents such as short-circuits, overloads, voltage dips, or earth faults. There exist different types of discrimination techniques that depend on the type of fault and prevent the electrical network from being affected. However, the goal is to isolate the faulty condition by operating only the nearest upstream overcurrent protective device.

Total and partial selectivity

There are two degrees of selectivity and the correspondent definitions are given in the Standard IEC 60947-2.

Total selectivity

Selectivity is total when for all fault values from overload to bolted short-circuits, distribution is totally selective if only the circuit breaker immediately upstream located above the fault opens.

“Overcurrent selectivity where in the presence of two protection devices against overcurrent in series, the load side protection device carries out the protection without making the other device trip.”

Partial selectivity

Selectivity is partial if the above condition is not fulfilled up to the bolted short-circuit current but only up to a lower value. This value is referred to as the selectivity limit.

“Overcurrent selectivity where, in the presence of two protection devices against overcurrent in series, the load side protection device carries out the protection up to a given level of overcurrent, without making the other device trip.”

elec calc: power continuity and selective coordination

Carrying out a discrimination study is critical to ensure the correct functioning of the electrical system in the event of possible faults. In fact, in the electrical power system designs, power continuity and selective coordination are the requirements to meet.

elec calc is a robust software that offers critical calculations for factors such as earthing systems, cable ampacity, short circuit currents, thermal stresses, voltage drops, and discrimination studies between protections that are key for the continuation of supply.

With elec calc you can check several operational scenarios such as emergency, network change-over – to analyze each operational condition using the behavior and sizing of the installation.

To guarantee project design calculation, quality, safety, and power supply, companies must comply with strict design rules. With elec calc it is possible to proactively save money and reduce costly errors in the design process with quick selection of manufacturer´ or users´ references and verification of installation sizing with the relevant standards.

elec calc complies with IEC standards (as well as many others) – electrical standards compliance – size according to the international and local standards, ensure the correct behavior of the installation and comply with regulations in force.

Domestic-type circuit-breakers must comply with IEC standard 60898, or an equivalent national standard.

{videobox}9SaI1hbhA1g{/videobox}

EC 60898-1

Defines the behavior of a circuit breaker in relation to AC. low-voltage circuit breakers – Miniature Circuit Breakers (MCBs) – we find in our homes, schools, shops, and offices electrical distribution switchboards.

The standard states that the top-rated current is 125A, while the lowest is 6A and the maximum value of rated short-circuit capacity (Icn) is 25kA. These basic tech specifications tell us how different the use of circuit breakers defined by our two standards are.

Industrial circuit-breakers must comply with IEC 60947-1 and 60947-2 or other equivalent standards.

IEC 60947-2

They protect electrical power distribution of up to 1000 volts AC and 1500 volts DC with the whole spectrum of rated current from 0,5 to 6300A. Utilities and manufacturing facilities use them: air circuit breakers (ACBs), Molded Case Circuit Breakers (MCCBs), and miniature circuit breakers (MCBs).

Safety can be combined with the continuity of service using elec calc and the fault easily located. It is an especially important point for high-powered equipment since this is generally located at the head of the installation and therefore has even greater consequences in the event of false tripping.

Real-time – elec calc with its unique features such as HV/LV real-time calculations, its intuitive and intelligent design mode, Intellisense, and its multi-level discrimination functionality, helps ensure the maintaining of power supplies. That is why elec calc features a discrimination study by a free selection of components along with a dynamic graphical setting of the device with an adjustable zoom.

All these factors are vital within the sector for energy production, energy transformation, or energy distribution.

That is why the correct type of discrimination study is essential. For each type of fault, there is a specific protective device (protection against overload, short-circuit or earth fault currents, or against loss of voltage, etc). Each of these faults can cause a loss of discrimination if the coordination of the protective devices has not been considered. elec calc software features all the necessary functions and features to carry out a complete analysis of installations with detailed studies, giving you the very best solution for your project.

Source

Related Articles


Changing Scene

  • SEW-Eurodrive: MAXOLUTION System Solutions

    SEW-Eurodrive: MAXOLUTION System Solutions

    Whether in production or logistics operations, MAXOLUTION is synonymous with innovation in factory automation – across all industries and worldwide – helping you achieve your vision of an adaptable and resilient lean smart factory. Under the MAXOLUTION brand, SEW-EURODRIVE creates customized solutions for cutting-edge materials handling technology – from the shop floor through to IT.… Read More…

  • 6 Ways the New maxon Website Enhances Your Experience

    6 Ways the New maxon Website Enhances Your Experience

    maxon develops drives that are among the best in the world. They advance technologies that save lives on Earth, make driving and flying safer, and enable the use of robots in space. Where uncompromising precision and the highest quality standards are crucial for success, their drive systems show what they are made of. Complexity is… Read More…


Sponsored Content
The Easy Way to the Industrial IoT

The way to the Industrial IoT does not have to be complicated. Whether access to valuable data is required or new, data-driven services are to be generated, Weidmuller enables its customers to go from data to value the easy way. Weidmuller’s comprehensive and cutting-edge IIoT portfolio applies to greenfield and brownfield applications. Weidmuller offers components and solutions from data acquisition, data pre-processing, data communication and data analysis.

Visit Weidmuller’s Industrial IoT Portfolio.


ADVANCED Motion Controls Takes Servo Drives to New Heights (and Depths) with FlexPro Extended Environment Product Line

Advanced Motion Controls is proud to announce the addition of six new CANopen servo drives with Extended Environment capabilities to their FlexPro line. These new drives join AMC’s existing EtherCAT Extended Environment FlexPro drives, making the FlexPro line the go-to solution for motion control applications in harsh environments.

Many motion control applications take place in conditions that are less than ideal, such as extreme temperatures, high and low pressures, shocks and vibrations, and contamination. Electronics, including servo drives, can malfunction or sustain permanent damage in these conditions.

Read More


Service Wire Co. Announces New Titles for Key Executives

Bruce Kesler and Mark Gatewood have been given new titles and responsibilities for Service Wire Co.

Bruce Kesler has assumed the role of Senior Director – Business Development. Bruce will be responsible for Service Wire’s largest strategic accounts and our growing Strategic Accounts Team.

Mark Gatewood has been promoted to the role of Vice President – Sales & Marketing. In this role, Gatewood will lead the efforts of Service Wire Company’s entire sales and marketing organization in all market verticals.

Read More


Tri-Mach Announces the Purchase of an Additional 45,000 sq ft. Facility

Tri-Mach Elmira Facility

Recently, Tri-Mach Inc. was thrilled to announce the addition of a new 45,000 sq ft. facility. Located at 285 Union St., Elmira, ON, this facility expands Tri-Mach’s capabilities, allowing them to better serve the growing needs of their customers.

Positioning for growth, this additional facility will allow Tri-Mach to continue taking on large-scale projects, enhance product performance testing, and provide equipment storage for their customers. The building will also be the new home to their Skilled Trades Centre of Excellence.

Read More


JMP Parent Company, CONVERGIX Acquires AGR Automation, Expanding Global Reach

Convergix Automation Solutions has completed the acquisition of AGR Automation (“AGR”), a UK-based provider of custom, high-performance automation design and systems integration primarily to the life sciences industry.

Following Convergix’s acquisitions of JMP Solutions in August 2021 and Classic Design in February 2022, AGR marks the third investment in Crestview’s strategy to build Convergix into a diversified automation solutions provider targeting the global $500+ billion market, with a particular focus on the $70 billion global systems integration and connectivity segments. Financial terms of the transaction were not disclosed.

Read More


Latest Articles

  • Making the Sustainable Transformation of the Process Industry a Success

    Making the Sustainable Transformation of the Process Industry a Success

    By Krystie Johnston and Dr. Manfred Jagiella – Sustainability facilitates opportunity when approached with a mindset to preserve resources and promote circularity. We share one Earth, and it is our global responsibility to care for it for the next generation. Endress+Hauser is one global company that understands this responsibility – and practices it as well.… Read More…

  • Why NOARK’s 12VDC Shunt Trip Coils for MCCBs Make Power Systems Reliable and Safer

    Why NOARK’s 12VDC Shunt Trip Coils for MCCBs Make Power Systems Reliable and Safer

    Circuit breakers are an essential component of any modern electrical system. Designed to protect your home or business from potential overloads or short circuits, these devices are your first line of defense against electrical fires. There are, however, situations where remote tripping of the circuit breaker may be required. It could be for operational reasons,… Read More…