Panel Builder System Integrator

MC How to Correctly Measure the Efficiency of a Power Supply by PULS 1 400x275

November 7, 2022

Manufacturers' data sheets often only give blanket information on efficiency and power losses of their power supplies at different mains voltages or loads. Therefore, it is advisable for users to measure the efficiency of a power supply themselves. In this blog article you will learn what you should pay attention to.

Multimeter, wattmeter, or power analyzer – which is the (measurement) tool of choice?

There are several measuring instruments which are used for the determination of efficiency. Nevertheless, the measurement tolerances and the capabilities of measuring instruments in measuring various signals (AC or DC) varies considerably.

Multimeters:

Accurate multimeters do a great job measuring the voltage and current of purely DC inputs and outputs. The voltage can be measured with high precision directly at the input and output of the power supply. Many multimeters also have built-in ability to measure current, but this is usually too inaccurate (inaccuracy of 1% or more) or it does not have sufficient measuring range (usually limited to 10A). Instead, the current should be measured by high precision shunt resistors with 0.01% tolerance. However, the non-synchronous detection of values can be problematic because it leads to errors if fluctuating conditions are present.

Watt meters:

Watt meters are used for measuring AC signals and follow the right principle. The instantaneous values of current and voltage are multiplied, and a mean value is calculated from these products – this corresponds to the physical definition of performance. However, most simple watt meters have a high measurement inaccuracy (around 1%). Moreover, frequently changing input or output currents (AC input, varying output load) cause additional measuring errors. Fluctuating values are thus difficult to interpret. Generally, only high-precision watt meters should be used when measuring efficiency.

Data loggers:

Data loggers are even better for DC measurements. They consist of a single, usually highly accurate meter, which is used several times by multiplexing. In the same measuring range, the errors even cancel off each other and all values can be promptly recorded and evaluated quickly with a spreadsheet.

Power analyzer: 

MC How to Correctly Measure Efficiency of a Power Supply by PULS 2 281x226

PULS uses power analyzers to measure the efficiency of its power supplies. (See image 1) The advantages of this are the high basic accuracy of 0.02%, the correct measuring of active power, the simultaneous and thus synchronous measuring of input and output, and the direct display of power losses and efficiency. The downside of this method of measuring is the high purchase price involved. Nevertheless, the power analyzer is the tool of choice for the accurate determination of efficiency. 

Image 1: The efficiency of PULS' switched-mode power supplies is measured with ultra-modern power analyzers.

Tip:

However, AC input power cannot be measured with multimeters or data loggers. It is a common mistake to assume that it is sufficient to measure the true RMS of the current and voltage and to multiply the two values to determine the input power. This calculation, however, determines the apparent power and not the real power which is crucial for the power losses. The measurement of AC input power, even with True RMS multimeters, thus gives incorrect measurements and is an absolute no-go.

Avoiding mistakes in the measurement setup

A precise and expensive power analyzer may however not provide accurate results if mistakes were made during the measurement setup.

MC How to Correctly Measure Efficiency of a Power Supply by PULS 3 166x365

Correct wiring:

All power losses that do not come from the device under test are not allowed to be included in the measurement! This is the main principle, when it comes to correct wiring in the measurement setup. Because every cable and every contact resistance cause additional power losses that may distort the measurement results. A proper four-pole measurement (Kelvin measurement) must have separate cables for the measurement of current and voltage. (See image 2)

Voltage source:

Simple DC voltage supplies are sufficient for switch-mode power supplies with DC-input. For AC measurements, it is important to know that the internal resistance of the voltage source influences the measurement through the curve shape of the mains sine. In a 240W power supply without PFC, a difference of 0.4% was measured between the soft power from an isolating regulating transformer and the hard power from an electronic AC source. This gives the most reproducible values and is therefore preferable.

Image 2: It is decisive to do the wiring correctly. A proper four-pole measurement (Kelvin measurement) with separate cables for the measurement of current and voltage is a must.

EMC interferences:

Unshielded power supplies in the prototype stage can interfere with meters and/or can cause loads to fluctuate. You should not accept any signals with HF interference from meters. Additional filters, mostly inductors in the input lines, prevent these problems. In addition, you should not allow power losses to flow into the measurement. There should be no problems with clean, radio interference- suppressed power supplies.

Loads:

Besides the power source, the used load must also be stable and reproducible. The loads from power resistors are problematic because they do not draw a constant current. However, electronic loads represent a defined and reproducible load of the device under test and even fluctuating transition resistances do not alter the current.

Taking environmental conditions into consideration

In respect to environmental conditions, temperature plays a decisive role, because the power losses from a power supply are temperature dependent. The temperature of the components in a power supply is a crucial factor. The component temperature is the sum of ambient temperature and self-heating.

Temperature:

The various components in the power supply react differently to temperature. In some essential elements, an increase in temperature results in a reduction of power losses. But in other components the losses increase. The NTCs used for limiting the input inrush current have a strong influence. Power supplies with such components have less power losses during the startup phase and in higher ambient temperatures (negative temperature coefficient), but at higher temperatures the increase of power loss is outweighed again by other essential elements. (See diagram 2)

Devices with active input inrush current limiter show a more stable temperature behaviour. Here there is only a small increase inpower loss from temperature. For all efficiency measurements, the startup time and the ambient temperature should be documented so that the results remain traceable.

MC How to Correctly Measure Efficiency of a Power Supply by PULS 4 430x292

MC How to Correctly Measure Efficiency of a Power Supply by PULS 5 430x292

 Diagram 2(Left): Due to the NTC, efficiency is highly dependent on time and temperature

 

Diagram 3(Right): The active input inrush current limiter without NTC gives an efficiency that is less time and temperature dependent.

MC How to Correctly Measure Efficiency of a Power Supply by PULS 6 549x405Altitude and air pressure:

Since cooling is done by air, the air pressure has an influence on self-heating. PULS has calculated how much additional heat is generated by components at a high altitude: by approx. + 10 °C at an altitude of 2,000 m above sea level and approx. + 20 °C at 4,000 m. Humidity plays only a very minor role and can be neglected.

Diagram 4: In the PULS production, an efficiency mean value of 95.27 % with a deviation of ±0.15 % was measured on a production batch of 200 devices of the type CP10

Sample distributions:

Each component has tolerances and therefore not every device is the same. But to find genuine errors, PULS measures power losses very closely even during production – although not quite as accurate as in the laboratory. A mean value of 95.27 % with a deviation of ±0.15 % was measured on a production batch of 200 devices of the type CP10 . (See diagram 4)

Conclusion

The correct efficiency measurement of switched-mode power supplies is complex. But it is worth questioning the manufacturer's data sheet information and measuring it yourself if necessary. PULS has been dealing with the exact measurement of the efficiency of its products for decades and is available to advise its customers on all questions. They have even set up their own team of experienced application engineers to provide application advice.

Source

ASK RITTAL SERIES
Episode 1 - A-Z of Busbar

ASkRittalBusbar_300__250_px_2.png

What are the advantages to using busbars in your panels?

The busbar is a very efficient part in the electrical panel that collects and transmits electrical energy as a conductor.  This conductor can pass very large currents.

Busbar allows for: 

  •    -   Reductions in the use of space relative to the panel and enclosure           (reduction in the amount of wiring). So, more equipment and parts             can be used in a panel.
  •    -   Easy troubleshooting in the event of switchgear interruption or                   failure.
  •    -   Time savings during both installation, maintenance, or upgrades               (ex.busbars are mostly used for branching inside panels, and,                   branching will be done by holes and bolts without using terminals).
  •    -   Integration of supplemental panel or enclosure elements to enhance or augment performance
  •    -   High electrical and mechanical strength. They last longer and don’t require regular replacement. They distribute power             more efficiently. Thus, reducing energy consumption.
  •    -   They’re also easily adaptable for renewable energy integration while offering extreme versatility for easy consumption                for many purposes.

Download the Recording Here

Changing Scene

  • Prev
Sonepar has announced that its wholly-owned Canadian subsidiary, Sonepar Canada, Inc. has acquired ...
EY Canada is pleased to welcome AFARA and its team of multidisciplinary consultants to the firm to ...
Rockwell Automation, Inc. recently announced that Tessa Myers has been named senior vice president, ...
Rittal Systems Ltd. has announced that its valued partner, Tusk Automation Inc. has been named a ...
We often hear that everything old becomes new again, which serves to highlight the importance of ...
Weidmuller Ltd. has signed a distribution partnership with Shelley Automation for the Ontario ...
Carlo Gavazzi (Canada) Inc. of Mississauga, ON, has appointed Dany Lavoie and Brett Horst to its ...
Omron Automation Americas announces RAMP Inc. as a new partner in its Certified System Integrator ...
Skilled tradespeople in British Columbia will benefit from a made-in-B.C. system to support and ...
Rittal Systems Ltd. is pleased to welcome their first Rittal Certified Systems Integrator of ...


Sonepar Acquires Aztec Electrical Supply Inc.

Sonepar Acquires Aztec

Sonepar has announced that its wholly-owned Canadian subsidiary, Sonepar Canada, Inc. has acquired Aztec Electrical Supply Inc. With a strong presence in the province of Ontario, the acquisition of Aztec will strengthen Sonepar’s ability to grow their industrial business model across the Greater Toronto Area.

Founded in 2002, Aztec expanded its market presence across Ontario opening four branches located within Vaughan, Cambridge, Mississauga, and Burlington. Aztec will add over 100 associates to the Sonepar network in Canada and is expected to record sales revenues of over $70 million in 2022.

Read More


Omron Announces REVTECH as Certified Systems Integrator Partner

 

Omron Partners with REVTECH

Omron Automation Americas recently announced REVTECH as a new partner in its Certified Systems Integrator program. Based near Quebec City, REVTECH has been providing robotic and automation solutions for companies of various sizes across industries.

REVTECH’s determination is unmatched when it comes to providing their customers with the industry’s most high-performing yet easy-to-use systems. The company focuses on production improvement, ROI, and easy technological transfer to users. They recently designed, built, and implemented a complex, multi-robot production cell using Omron robots, Sysmac control, and high-resolution FH vision, all in a safe package for the user.

Read More


For a Multiplied Value Unified

PB-62-Excelpro-MultipliedValue-400.jpg

During the last few years, the Excelpro Group has welcomed AIA Automation, Envitech Automation and Conrad Lavoie Electrical, all of which have become ‘Member of the Excelpro Group’.

It is with great excitement that Excelpro announced that these three companies officially became Excelpro.

This decision is part of a strategy to enhance the Excelpro Group’s brand in its market.

These companies already collaborate on various client projects. This merger brings together the complementary strengths of the employees and ensures a global synergy of the activities throughout the Group.

Read More


 

Q&A With HELU: Robotic Dress Packs

HELU Robotic Systems

Robots are an integral part of the manufacturing industry worldwide to the extent that they are indispensable. In production, robots and cobots frequently encounter each other, working and interacting side by side with humans, but also performing tasks independently.

The latest industrial robots move in a three-dimensional space and can therefore perform a wide variety of tasks. In order to ensure optimum system performance, the use of a dress pack is required to keep a robot running as frequently as possible. Regional Sales Manager Gordon Post discusses some of the questions he hears in the field about robotic cable protection systems.

Read More


 


Can A Cobot Help Your End-of-Line Operations?

Cobot

 

If you’re challenged with labor issues in your packaging and palletizing area, you’re not alone.  These applications are often tedious and can lead to repetitive motion injuries. In a tight job market it’s especially difficult to fill jobs that people consider dull and strenuous. Now more than ever, companies are looking for automation solutions that will allow them to resolve labor issues and increase their flexibility to quickly adapt to market demands.

Can a cobot help your end-of-line operations?   Here are a few areas to consider:

Case Erecting - Some companies have very limited space or they have "odd ball" box sizes that can’t be erected with a traditional case erector.

Read More

 


 

Product News

  • Prev
With the new Cosy+ Wireless, HMS Networks finalizes the release of the new generation of Ewon ...
Littelfuse, Inc. introduces a new ground-fault knowledge center for engineers, electricians, ...
AutomationDirect has added new stainless-steel specialty inductive proximity sensors from ...
Control of wastewater treatment plants is a complex task requiring thousands of measurement devices ...
Allied Electronics & Automation is now stocking Schneider Electric’s new Altivar ATS480 soft ...
For the first time in machine and system engineering, the MX-System enables completely control ...
The POWER CAGE CLAMP provides the proper clamping force for conductors up to 35, 50, 95 and ...
SCHUNK has developed a versatile gripper for small components for handling of delicate and fragile ...
Introducing the CWG Series Type 1 Galvanized Lay-In Wireway from Hammond Manufacturing, with a ...
An all-in-one control platform for applications requiring high-speed processing, machine control, ...

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2022 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil